News and Events

The Advantages of Non-Destructive Testing (NDT) Techniques for Evaluating the Compressive Strength of In-Place Concrete

posted 11.17.2017

The evaluation of compressive strength of in-place concrete is often needed for projects of new constructions, structural additions and remodeling, and structural repairs. Traditional method of testing the compressive strength of concrete cores retrieved from a structure can be time-consuming and possibly damaging to the structure when a large number of structural members are under evaluation.  Alternative methods that reduce the needs of coring and cause no damage or limited superficial local damage to the structure are becoming more popular.

Non-Destructive Testing (NDT) Techniques

Non-destructive testing (NDT) techniques of evaluating in-place concrete strength measure some properties of concrete which can be correlated to the compressive strength of concrete cores. The well-known guidance of performing in-place concrete strength estimation are ACI 228.1R and ACI 228.2R which are issued by American Concrete Institute (ACI) Committee 228. Pullout testing is recommended by ACI 228.2R as the primary method of estimating the compressive strength of in-place concrete based on accuracy compared to other NDT techniques.

Test Methods for Determining Material Properties of Hardened Concrete in Existing Construction (referencing ACI 228.2R-13 Table 4.1.1)

Property Method
Primary Secondary
Compressive strength (ACI

228.1R)

Cores for compression testing

(ASTM C42/C42M and C39/C39M);

pullout testing (post-installed)

(ASTM C900)

Penetration resistance (ASTM C803/ C803M)
Relative compressive

strength

Rebound number (ASTM C805/

C805M); Ultrasonic Pulse Velocity (UPV) (ASTM C597)

In-place pulloff test (ACI 503.1R:

BS 1881-207) with appropriate

calibration.

NDT Techniques Prevents Project Delays

Pullout-TestThe Terracon team recently worked with a client on a project where a sixteen-story steel framing structure is proposed to be built on an existing twelve-year-old one-story reinforced concrete structure. The concrete mixture design information and concrete material testing records for the in-place concrete were not available to the client. To assist the client in determining if the existing reinforced concrete structure had sufficient capacity to carry the load from the proposed steel structure, pullout testing was performed on three footings and twenty-nine plinths which were identified as critical structural members by the structural engineer of record.

Terracon performed both core strength testing and pullout testing on 15 structural concrete members to develop a job-specific strength correlation. Once the strength correlation was established, the in-place concrete strength of additional members was estimated with pullout testing only. Pullout testing at each additional location was completed in about 40 minutes total from sample preparation to strength estimation The results indicated that the concrete compressive strengths were structurally adequate per the acceptance criteria given by ACI 221.1R. The pullout testing procedure allowed for testing of more locations more efficiently than if only testing core samples. A significant delay in project schedule was avoided.

Pullout testing is just one of the several NDT techniques that Terracon uses to evaluate in-place concrete strength, depending on project variables. Terracon is experienced with field and laboratory testing and statistical analysis, which assures NDT options that can be coordinated with the client and reliable and resourceful services are delivered in a cost-efficient and time-saving manner.


Zhengqi (Jason) Li, Ph.D., E.I.T., LEED AP,  Jason is a staff engineer in our Houston office. He performs concrete diagnostics services including non-destructive testing and research on concrete materials and structures.

Jigar Desai, Ph.D., P.E., Jigar is office manager as part of Terracon’s Facilities Services team in our Houston office. He serves as a technical leader in Terracon’s Engineering Diagnostics services and consults on materials/structural diagnostics projects with a focus on concrete structures.

Wesley Bullock, P.E., Wesley is a project engineer in the facilities evaluation services department in our Birmingham, AL office. Wesley performs structural diagnostics and structural repair and rehabilitation consulting services.